The storyline was a bit sluggish for a majority of that book。 There were also several POVs that made it hard to know which character is which。 This made it hard to connect with the characters as well。I won’t be picking this book back up to reread。
Emily,
Decent suburban thriller that keeps you guessing。
Kylee,
The first half of the book had too many characters it was hard to keep up。 Once I finally knew them all though I did end up enjoying the book!
Emily,
If you’ve seen Big Little Lies, you have essentially read this book。
Leann Moore,
WHAT A FUN READ!I'm a sucker for a multi-POV book with multiple mysteries tied into it, and this one did not disappoint。 I flew through it, but did have to make a small chart to keep up with who was related to who。 Highly recommend this for anyone looking for something a little less tense and a way to escape。 WHAT A FUN READ!I'm a sucker for a multi-POV book with multiple mysteries tied into it, and this one did not disappoint。 I flew through it, but did have to make a small chart to keep up with who was related to who。 Highly recommend this for anyone looking for something a little less tense and a way to escape。 。。。more
Erin,
3。5 rounded up。 The ending of this book required a massive amount of suspension of disbelief and also kind of came out of left field, so subtracting stars for that。 However, I really felt like the author nailed what it’s like to be a parent today and how you worry so much about your kids and think other people have it easier when that’s not always the case。 I think as long as you manage your expectations, this wound up being an entertaining read。
Randi,
2。5 rounded up。 A bit boring overall。
Ellie,
Solid funny, enjoyable, casual read。
Patty,
3。5 stars。 This was one of my September Book Of The Month selections。 There were a lot of characters to keep straight 。 。 。 I liked it, but don’t think it will leave a lasting impression。
Elizabeth Dietz,
Would give this a 3。5/5 stars。 Had some twists and terms I wasn’t expecting and I had a hard time getting in to it, but by the end I enjoyed it!
Reagan Peoples,
3。5/5 ⭐️
Rachel Dodson,
It was a good book just not what I was expecting! Loads of characters that made it difficult to keep up with them。 Thought more would have been done with the vandals。 Good quick read。
Rebecca,
Characters were hard to follow at first, with interchanging POV。 It ended up gaining momentum as the story went on, and I loved how it wrapped everything up at the end, with no questions left hanging。 I didn’t expect some of the plot twists。。 overall, solid read
Lisa,
This book had so much potential。 It follows the stories of Annie, Lena, and Jen in the Cottonwood Estates neighborhood。 All have their own secrets and throughout the book we learn what those are。 I liked Jen's story because her thought process was pretty clear, but Annie and Lena's stories were so vague and their connection felt odd and didn't make sense until the very end。 The last 30 pages literally felt like the author was handing out plot twists and trying to one-up the last one and they rea This book had so much potential。 It follows the stories of Annie, Lena, and Jen in the Cottonwood Estates neighborhood。 All have their own secrets and throughout the book we learn what those are。 I liked Jen's story because her thought process was pretty clear, but Annie and Lena's stories were so vague and their connection felt odd and didn't make sense until the very end。 The last 30 pages literally felt like the author was handing out plot twists and trying to one-up the last one and they really seemed out of the blue。 This book was missing something for me to make me really love it but it was overall ok。 。。。more
Traci Simons,
This one had me guessing the whole way。 Maybe because I wasn’t super focused when reading, but I really did enjoy it。
Lisa Ponti,
A bit torn on this one。 The mystery part of the story is as good…many turns I didn’t expect for sure but I really didn’t like most of the characters, found most of them annoying。 Could be because I don’t have children but I found a lot of their issues first world problems that I couldn’t emphasize with。
Jennie Maier,
Good easy read。 Lotta deception and faded memories。 A lot of secrets。 Who knew a teenage pregnancy secret too。 And kinda figured out who killed one guy but didn’t see the second death coming!! I liked it
Erin,
It's well-written, but the characters are annoying。 Annie is ridiculously unprofessional。 She acts like a teenager。 Jen is overly defensive and willfully blind。 The plot works and effectively reveals enough details of what happened 15 years before and during the course of the book。 The ending is sufficient。 The last chapter is a bit too much, but it feels like the author really wanted to give us a better idea of the long-term effects on the characters。A minor note, but it's frustrating for a boo It's well-written, but the characters are annoying。 Annie is ridiculously unprofessional。 She acts like a teenager。 Jen is overly defensive and willfully blind。 The plot works and effectively reveals enough details of what happened 15 years before and during the course of the book。 The ending is sufficient。 The last chapter is a bit too much, but it feels like the author really wanted to give us a better idea of the long-term effects on the characters。A minor note, but it's frustrating for a book to mention asexuality, but to do so incorrectly。 It's only the one reference when Jen is speculating about another character, and she describes celibacy。 She clearly doesn't understand asexual is an orientation, since she describes it as a movement, specifically linking it to a religious movement。 Asexuality is so rarely mentioned that it's incredibly frustrating to see misconceptions spread without any effort to acknowledge that the information was wrong。 。。。more
Jamie Oliver,
This was…underwhelming。 Way too many characters。 There wasn’t really a plot, just a bunch of mini sub-plots instead。 Forgettable。 I won’t remember anything about this book in 2 days。 It had potential but it missed the mark for me。 😴
Drea,
Bummer。 Is it because none of the characters were likeable - or perhaps because the multiple POV’s seemed muddled and needlessly sporadic - or maybe because the plot tried to be clever but fell short into trying to hard to be clever and twisty? Who knows。 I had high hopes and this left me checking how many more pages were left in each chapter to see how much more there was to read - never a good sign。 Clever premise with how each section starts with a book club selection - but what a bummer beca Bummer。 Is it because none of the characters were likeable - or perhaps because the multiple POV’s seemed muddled and needlessly sporadic - or maybe because the plot tried to be clever but fell short into trying to hard to be clever and twisty? Who knows。 I had high hopes and this left me checking how many more pages were left in each chapter to see how much more there was to read - never a good sign。 Clever premise with how each section starts with a book club selection - but what a bummer because that was my favorite parts of this novel - to see what they were reading every month。 Thanks to Flatiron for the advanced copy。 This one was a miss but I’m so grateful for the opportunity to read and review it。 。。。more
Sandi Christiansen,
It’s rare that a story is told from different perspectives and somehow I want to hear all of them。 This was well written and riveting。 Loved it。
Kimberly Cassada,
I read this book in one day and wow- I loved every bit of it。 Short chapters & I couldn’t put it down。 What a fun read 🤗
Emily,
Like 4。5 stars。 Really solid domestic drama。
Lori,
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers。 To view it, click here。 Extremely well done。 Did not anticipate the ending, even though you could see how the individual characters were eventually being woven together into the the final tapestry-- its not often I don't anticipate the ending, and that it still does not feel contrived。 Glad I read the physical book rather than on kindle since I needed to go back and re-read the "notes" from the character who figured it out to see how it had come together for them。 It would have been hard to find those specific pages on Extremely well done。 Did not anticipate the ending, even though you could see how the individual characters were eventually being woven together into the the final tapestry-- its not often I don't anticipate the ending, and that it still does not feel contrived。 Glad I read the physical book rather than on kindle since I needed to go back and re-read the "notes" from the character who figured it out to see how it had come together for them。 It would have been hard to find those specific pages on a kindle。 。。。more
Krystle Meyer,
There's a group of women who live in a bougey neighborhood who have a book club。 The story is centered around multiple viewpoints from the book club women - all of whom seem to be having various issues with their children, husbands, or pasts。 So I thought the writing was fine, but this story was a big MEH。 The book is billed as having a vandal who is running around destroying the neighborhood in increasingly dangerous ways (i。e。, graffiti in the shape of a dick to something more nefarious) but t There's a group of women who live in a bougey neighborhood who have a book club。 The story is centered around multiple viewpoints from the book club women - all of whom seem to be having various issues with their children, husbands, or pasts。 So I thought the writing was fine, but this story was a big MEH。 The book is billed as having a vandal who is running around destroying the neighborhood in increasingly dangerous ways (i。e。, graffiti in the shape of a dick to something more nefarious) but there's maybe four solid pages about the vandal? It's more a story of two women - Annie and Lena - and what they're hiding from everyone else。 Also too many main characters - made it confusing。If you have nothing better to read, read this。 。。。more
Marcela,
3。5 ⭐I had a difficult time getting into this book, probably because I read in small bits。 The chapters were short, so just as you were figuring out one character/family you moved on to another。 Which is probably why I never connected with any of the characters。 I was probably 2/3 through the book before I didn't have to stop and think who was who at the start of each chapter。Overall, the story was good, just very choppy。BOTM 9/21 3。5 ⭐I had a difficult time getting into this book, probably because I read in small bits。 The chapters were short, so just as you were figuring out one character/family you moved on to another。 Which is probably why I never connected with any of the characters。 I was probably 2/3 through the book before I didn't have to stop and think who was who at the start of each chapter。Overall, the story was good, just very choppy。BOTM 9/21 。。。more
Heidi McLaughlin,
I really enjoyed the build up of this book。 The way the story unfolded kept me hooked。
Rebecca,
I thought the beginning was so confusing understanding the various story lines。 If there was a family tree from the start (whos married to who / children) I think that could have provided clarity。 The big reveal wasn't that surprising a bit letdown as this was my first BOM pick。 I thought the beginning was so confusing understanding the various story lines。 If there was a family tree from the start (whos married to who / children) I think that could have provided clarity。 The big reveal wasn't that surprising a bit letdown as this was my first BOM pick。 。。。more
Becky,
I enjoyed this one! I had an idea about some of the ending but not all of it!The book club as a way to tie it all together definitely was a bonus。